Picture this: You're looking across your team and suddenly notice someone with that special spark – perhaps they don't see it yet, but you recognize the makings of an exceptional leader. What you do next could transform not just their career, but the future of your entire organization.
After two decades of building and scaling teams, I've learned that growing future leaders isn't just part of a leader's job – it's one of our most crucial responsibilities. Here are three powerful ways to identify and nurture leadership potential in your team.
1. Look Beyond the Obvious Stars
Every leader has made this mistake: identifying your highest-performing individual contributor and automatically assuming they'll make a great leader. I've done it myself, pushing technical stars toward leadership roles only to watch both of us become frustrated when the transition failed.
Here's what I've learned: Leadership potential often hides in unexpected places.
While your top performers might indeed become great leaders, focusing solely on technical excellence means missing out on incredible leadership talent that manifests in subtler ways.
Think about your own career journey. Were you always the obvious choice for leadership? For many of us, someone else saw our potential before we did. That's why it's crucial to look deeper than surface-level performance metrics.
Signs of Hidden Leadership Potential:
🎯 The Consistent Winner
Repeatedly delivers results despite obstacles
Finds creative solutions to challenges
Never gives up, even when things get tough
🤝 The Quiet Influencer
Team naturally gravitates to their opinion
Others seek their advice informally
Makes impact without authority
🔍 The Business Mind
Asks questions about larger company goals
Connects technical decisions to business impact
Shows interest in stakeholder perspectives
❤️ The Team Champion
Notices when colleagues are struggling
Offers help without being asked
Builds bridges across team divisions
🌱 The Growth Seeker
Embraces uncomfortable situations
Actively seeks feedback
Views challenges as learning opportunities
💡 LEADERSHIP ACCELERATOR Next time you observe these traits in action, try this approach:
Document specific examples of when you've seen these behaviors
Schedule a casual coffee chat
Share what you've observed and ask about their career aspirations
Listen more than you speak
2. Create Safe Spaces for Leadership Experiments
One of the most powerful lessons I've learned came from a talented developer who finally admitted they had zero interest in traditional leadership roles. We'd spent months exploring leadership opportunities before reaching this realization. While this might sound like a failure, it was actually a success – we'd created an environment safe enough for honest communication about career aspirations.
This experience fundamentally changed how I approach leadership development. Instead of pushing people toward predetermined paths, I learned to create safe spaces for exploration and experimentation. Think of it like a laboratory where potential leaders can test different aspects of leadership without fear of failure or permanent commitment.
The Leadership Laboratory Blueprint:
Stage 1: Low-Stakes Experiments
Lead a small project team (2-3 people)
Mentor one new team member
Run weekly team meetings
Stage 2: Expanded Responsibility
Represent team in cross-functional meetings
Lead technical decision-making processes
Coordinate with external stakeholders
Stage 3: Leadership Integration
Own key initiatives end-to-end
Build and execute team strategies
Develop other team members
POWER MOVE: When setting up these experiments, explicitly state: "This is an opportunity to explore, not a commitment to a path. Your value to this team doesn't depend on pursuing leadership."
3. Invest in Long-Term Growth
Early in my career, I made a critical mistake: expecting new leaders to emerge fully formed after a few weeks of guidance. This mindset not only set unrealistic expectations but also created unnecessary pressure that stifled natural leadership development.
The reality is that growing leaders is more like tending a garden than building a structure. You can't force growth, but you can create optimal conditions for it to occur naturally. This means committing to a long-term development approach that allows for organic growth, occasional setbacks, and individual paths to leadership.
Your Growth Investment Strategy:
First 90 Days - Building Awareness
Focus on identifying leadership moments in daily work
Provide immediate feedback on natural leadership behaviors
Help potential leaders recognize their own impact
3-6 Months - Developing Core Skills
Create structured opportunities to lead small initiatives
Introduce key leadership concepts through real-world application
Build confidence through successful small wins
6-12 Months - Expanding Impact
Gradually increase responsibility while maintaining support
Encourage development of personal leadership style
Create opportunities for meaningful team influence
Beyond Year One - Refining Leadership Style
Provide ongoing mentorship and guidance
Support development of other leaders
Help navigate increasingly complex leadership challenges
The Multiplier Effect
When you successfully grow one leader, you're not just developing one person – you're creating someone who can develop others. This multiplier effect is how strong organizational cultures are built and sustained.
In five years, would you rather have developed five strong leaders who can each develop five more, or remain the sole source of leadership in your organization?
The choice – and the opportunity – is yours.
To your team’s exponential leadership journey,
Josh Anderson
Editor-In-Chief
The Leadership Lighthouse
Want to dive deeper into identifying and growing future leaders? Check out our recent podcast episode where we explore these concepts in detail, including real-world examples of successful (and unsuccessful) leadership development efforts.
Share your experiences with growing leaders in your organization. What approaches have worked for you? What challenges have you faced? Let's learn from each other's journeys.